Story

Choices and Consequences

The decisions the story hands you, mission by mission, with what each option leads to. Most only change the scenes you see; a few decide whether you get a reward.

Spoiler-freeUpdated 20 Nov 2026

In short

  • Most choices so far only change which scenes you see. Both options finish the mission and pay the same.
  • A few decide whether you get the rest of a job. In Dubious Provenance, saying no in Part 1 or 2 closes off the later parts and their payout.
  • Choices that give away the plot are behind spoiler blocks. Tap to reveal them.

Each mission below has a choice you make in the moment. The list grows as we write more of the walkthrough, and every mission page has the same box near the top.

Note

First pass. These come from mission guides that agree with each other, not yet from our own playthrough.

Chapter 1

Mission 08Hey Arnold!

01What happens to Arnold?

SpoilerThe optionsTap to reveal
  • Spare himHe does not come back, and nothing else in the game changes.
  • Don't spare himThe same: he is gone either way, and nothing else changes.

Mission 11Coming Home

01How much do you get ready before the pickup?

  • All five errandsThe relationship with Lucia starts at three of four hearts. Check it in the Jason and Lucia menu.
  • Buy the necklaceWorth doing either way: it comes back later, in Chapter 2.

Chapter 2

Mission 32Afternoon Delight

01Does Jason help out backstage?

  • HelpJason dances on stage while Lucia goes for the office alone. Longer, with more scenes.
  • Don't helpJason fires into the ceiling and both go for the safe. Quicker, but the chase after is harder.
  • Either waySame ending, same $10,000.

Mission 33Thrillbillies

01Which bike do you rent?

  • SanchezCosts more but is faster. The better finish usually pays the difference back.
  • ManchezCheaper and slower.

Mission 34Twist Wrist, Smash, Grab

01What do you do with the security guard?

  • Knock him outFine.
  • Leave himAlso fine. The mission carries on the same.

Chapter 3

Mission 36Welcome to Vice City

01Take Dre'Quan's cash for the dancers?

  • Take itSpend it on the dancers, then go back to Dre’Quan.
  • Turn it downGo straight back to Dre’Quan. No difference to the mission is reported.

Mission 37Dealer's Choice

01Cut or Pure?

  • PureThe buyer checks it and pays without any trouble.
  • CutTyrone says it could earn you more, but the buyer notices. You can offer it at half price.
  • Either wayThe mission ends the same, and neither option is reported to affect later missions.

Mission 39Dubious ProvenanceMissable

01Hand the statue to Halifax?

  • YesHe gives you his Crowex watch as a deposit, and Part 2 follows later.
  • NoAn optional call to Halifax stays open until the end of Chapter 3. Miss it and Parts 2 and 3 are gone.

02Trust Halifax at the motel?

  • Trust himPart 3 opens.
  • Don'tPart 3 does not open.

03Shoot or spare Halifax at the end?

  • ShootNo later effect reported so far.
  • SpareNo later effect reported so far.

Mission 43Here, Kitty Kitty

01Pay for the tip, or search the apartment?

  • Pay $20A neighbour tells you where Charles went.
  • Search the apartmentA clue inside points you to the same place, and you keep the $20.
  • Either wayBoth lead to the camp in La Perle and the mission plays out the same.

Mission 57Safe Word

01Does Jason take part further in the shoot?

  • NoThe safe pick: it keeps Lucia happy, and the mission goes on exactly the same.
  • YesLucia isn’t pleased. Nothing we know of changes in the mission itself.

Chapter 4

Mission 64Company Cars

01Which cars do you take?

  • Pfister Comet S2The best base stats of the cars on offer: the pick if you want speed.
  • A truck or an SUV for one of themA more mixed pair. Both cars are yours to keep, modify, upgrade or sell afterwards.

Mission 69Making Gainz

01Does Lucia take what Nate offers her?

  • No (default)The answer you get if you don’t change it. Nothing else we know of changes.
  • YesYou have to pick it on purpose. It changes how Lucia’s body looks for the rest of the game.

FAQ

Quick answers

Do choices matter in GTA 6?
Mostly for what you see, not where the story goes. In the missions covered here, both options finish the mission, and the ones that pay out pay the same. The exceptions are optional parts of a job: turning someone down can lock you out of later parts and their rewards.
Can a choice make you miss something in GTA 6?
Yes. In Dubious Provenance, if you don’t give Halifax the statue and never make the optional call afterwards, Parts 2 and 3 are gone once Chapter 3 ends, along with about $2,500 and a '32 Hustler. It does not block the story or 100% completion.
Should you trust Halifax in GTA 6?
If you want the whole job, yes. Only trusting him at the motel opens Part 3 of Dubious Provenance, where the cash and the '32 Hustler are.
Should Jason take part further in Safe Word?
There’s no need. Saying no has no downside, the mission carries on the same, and it’s the choice that keeps Lucia happy.
Does it matter if Jason helps in Afternoon Delight?
No. Helping is the longer route with more scenes; not helping is quicker with a harder chase. Both end the same way and pay $10,000.