Story mission 39 · Chapter 3
Dubious Provenance
Jason and Lucia take a statue to an antique dealer in Capri. A three-part job, and only the first part is required. Two choices in part one and two decide whether you see the rest and its payout.
Read before you start. You cannot come back for these after the mission ends.
- Parts 2 and 3, with their cash and the '32 Hustler. If you turn Halifax down in Part 1, an optional call to him stays open, but it disappears when Chapter 3 ends. Without it the later parts can’t be played. It does not block the story or 100%.
Mission objectives
What the game asks of you
- Take the statue to the antique store in Capri
- Optional: explore Capri together
- Get into Evelyn Andrews Antiques
- Let Jason in
- Find the statue
- Search the motel for Halifax
- Go to the address Evelyn gives you
- Chase Halifax
- Call Jason
Decisions
3 choices in this mission
What you can pick, and what we know each option leads to.
01Hand the statue to Halifax?
- YesHe gives you his Crowex watch as a deposit, and Part 2 follows later.
- NoAn optional call to Halifax stays open until the end of Chapter 3. Miss it and Parts 2 and 3 are gone.
02Trust Halifax at the motel?
- Trust himPart 3 opens.
- Don'tPart 3 does not open.
03Shoot or spare Halifax at the end?
- ShootNo later effect reported so far.
- SpareNo later effect reported so far.
Step by step
The walkthrough
Tap a step number to tick it off. Your place is saved in this browser.
Opens after Dealer’s Choice. It starts from a bag in the closet of the new apartment in Bayside, and it comes in three parts spread over the chapter. Part 1 moves the story on; Parts 2 and 3 are optional but pay well.
If you want the whole job, say yes to Halifax in Part 1 and trust him in Part 2. Saying no to either one closes off what comes after.
Part 1: take the statue to Capri
Interact with the bag in the closet of the Bayside apartment. Then head for Capri on the far west side of the map. You can drive, or call a RideMe taxi to save the trip.
TipAn optional objective asks you to explore Capri together. It goes away as soon as you walk into a shop or leave town, and you don’t need to do anything for it.
Part 1: the antique store
Try the front door of the store and the game takes you upstairs. The owner, Evelyn, won’t value the statue, but a man called Halifax offers to do it for you.
Hand it over and he leaves you his Crowex watch as a deposit. You can wear it: open a wardrobe and look under Accessories, then Watches.
MissableTurned him down? You can still phone Halifax later and give him the statue. That optional call vanishes when Chapter 3 ends, and Parts 2 and 3 go with it.
Part 2: break into the store
After a while Halifax goes quiet, and the next part starts back at the store. Wait for Evelyn to leave. You can force the door, or take the quiet way in below.
Part 2: in through the window
Go round the back of the building, climb the stairs and drop onto the lower roof. The window above the air conditioning unit is open. Inside, walk to the door and it opens for Jason.
Part 2: the drawer and the motel
Search the desk drawer in the north corner of the room. It leads you to the motel next door. Ask one of the people staying there, who points you to an upstairs room on the west side, then knock on that door.
Part 2: trust him or not
After the scene you decide whether to trust Halifax. Only trusting him leads to Part 3.
Part 3: Evelyn’s tip
Some time later Evelyn gets in touch. Go back to the store to talk to her, and she gives you an address in the northwest part of Capri.
Part 3: the chase on the water
When you get there, Halifax runs for a boat. Jason takes a Seashark after him. Get alongside and hold the prompt to jump onto his boat. He wrecks it and runs, so swim to shore and keep after him.
Part 3: golf cart and bike
He steals a golf cart. Grab the motorbike in the yard and stay on him.
Part 3: Lucia ends it
Halifax hits Jason with pepper spray, and the game switches to Lucia as he runs into her car. Get out, use focus mode (L3 and R3 together) and shoot him in the leg. Walk up to him, then call Jason on Lucia’s phone.
Part 3: the storage container
Search the storage container for about $2,500 in cash and jewellery. A '32 Hustler is parked in there too: keep it or sell it. You also get to decide whether to shoot Halifax or let him go.
NoteNeither guide we checked reports any later effect from shooting or sparing him.
Payoff
Rewards and what's next
Reported: every fact here comes from a trusted walkthrough, or from two that agree. Written in our own words. Last updated 19 Nov 2026.
Spotted a mistake or a missing step? Tell us.